Never Miss Another Deal!

No Fuss Deal Surprise Me

Identity Games Secret of the Scientist Review: A Clever Jigsaw and Escape Room Hybrid

The Identity Games [www.identity Games.com] Escape Room is a clever jigsaw and escape room hybrid, best for jigsaw fans. Rated 4.4 out of 5 across 595 user ratings. The main drawback: difficulty can feel uneven. We scored it 4.2 out of 5.

By Athena, Home & Family Editor Published July 11, 2026 Updated October 4, 2026
4.2Our score
Escape Room: Puzzle Adventures - Secret of The Scientist Jigsaw Puzzle & Escape Room Board | 1-2 Players - Games for Family Game Night | for Kids and Adults Ages 16+ | English Version Escape Room: Puzzle Adventures - Secret of The Scientist Jigsaw Puzzle & Escape Room Board | 1-2 Players - Games for Family Game Night | for Kids and Adults Ages 16+ | English Version, view 2 Escape Room: Puzzle Adventures - Secret of The Scientist Jigsaw Puzzle & Escape Room Board | 1-2 Players - Games for Family Game Night | for Kids and Adults Ages 16+ | English Version, view 3 Escape Room: Puzzle Adventures - Secret of The Scientist Jigsaw Puzzle & Escape Room Board | 1-2 Players - Games for Family Game Night | for Kids and Adults Ages 16+ | English Version, view 4 Escape Room: Puzzle Adventures - Secret of The Scientist Jigsaw Puzzle & Escape Room Board | 1-2 Players - Games for Family Game Night | for Kids and Adults Ages 16+ | English Version, view 5 Escape Room: Puzzle Adventures - Secret of The Scientist Jigsaw Puzzle & Escape Room Board | 1-2 Players - Games for Family Game Night | for Kids and Adults Ages 16+ | English Version, view 6 Escape Room: Puzzle Adventures - Secret of The Scientist Jigsaw Puzzle & Escape Room Board | 1-2 Players - Games for Family Game Night | for Kids and Adults Ages 16+ | English Version, view 7 Escape Room: Puzzle Adventures - Secret of The Scientist Jigsaw Puzzle & Escape Room Board | 1-2 Players - Games for Family Game Night | for Kids and Adults Ages 16+ | English Version, view 8 Escape Room: Puzzle Adventures - Secret of The Scientist Jigsaw Puzzle & Escape Room Board | 1-2 Players - Games for Family Game Night | for Kids and Adults Ages 16+ | English Version, view 9 Escape Room: Puzzle Adventures - Secret of The Scientist Jigsaw Puzzle & Escape Room Board | 1-2 Players - Games for Family Game Night | for Kids and Adults Ages 16+ | English Version, view 10 Escape Room: Puzzle Adventures - Secret of The Scientist Jigsaw Puzzle & Escape Room Board | 1-2 Players - Games for Family Game Night | for Kids and Adults Ages 16+ | English Version, view 11 Escape Room: Puzzle Adventures - Secret of The Scientist Jigsaw Puzzle & Escape Room Board | 1-2 Players - Games for Family Game Night | for Kids and Adults Ages 16+ | English Version, view 12 Escape Room: Puzzle Adventures - Secret of The Scientist Jigsaw Puzzle & Escape Room Board | 1-2 Players - Games for Family Game Night | for Kids and Adults Ages 16+ | English Version, view 13 Escape Room: Puzzle Adventures - Secret of The Scientist Jigsaw Puzzle & Escape Room Board | 1-2 Players - Games for Family Game Night | for Kids and Adults Ages 16+ | English Version, view 14 Escape Room: Puzzle Adventures - Secret of The Scientist Jigsaw Puzzle & Escape Room Board | 1-2 Players - Games for Family Game Night | for Kids and Adults Ages 16+ | English Version, view 15
Product gallery, 15 images

Prices shown were correct on October 4, 2026 and change frequently.

TL;DRThe Short Answer: Is the Identity Games [www.identity Games.com] Escape Room Worth It?

Most boxed escape games are either riddle books with a bit of cardboard or jigsaws with a riddle tacked on at the end. Secret of the Scientist genuinely blends the two: you open an advent-calendar box section by section, build a small jigsaw of each room, and solve the riddles hidden in it to work out which compartment comes next. The riddles are tough but fair, the final puzzle has a satisfying twist, and it works with or without a timer. The frustrations are a confusing first section while you learn the decoder, and the occasional box that arrives missing a component. It suits one or two players over an evening or a few short sessions.

NoFussDeal rates the Identity Games [www.identity Games.com] Escape Room 4.2 out of 5 at $26.99. Last updated October 4, 2026.

Key Facts

Item Dimensions L x W
13.07"L x 1.69"W
Item Dimensions
13.5 x 9 x 2 inches
Material Type
Cardboard
Item Weight
0.69 kg
Included Components
Puzzle game
Age Range Description
Age 16+

What Stands Out

  1. Five puzzle sections, opened in stages like an advent calendar, that assemble into one larger image of a mansion
  2. A puzzle-style decoder included to convert riddle answers into a symbol that reveals which compartment to open next
  3. Playable with or without a time limit, for one to two players
  4. A single continuous mystery story that runs from the first compartment to the last

Strengths and Drawbacks

What works

  • Solving riddles to earn new puzzle pieces gives the format a genuine escape-room feel rather than a plain jigsaw.
  • You can play with a timer for pressure or without one for a relaxed pace, and both approaches work well.
  • Riddles are challenging but can be reasoned out, and the final puzzle has a satisfying twist.
  • It splits well between two players, with one on the jigsaw and one on the riddles.
  • Nothing is written on or destroyed, so it can be repacked and passed on to someone else afterward.

What does not

  • Difficulty can feel uneven, with the first section noticeably the hardest.
  • The instructions are thin, and the decoder is confusing until you have used it once.
  • Some boxes arrive with a component missing from a compartment, and there's no manufacturer warranty to fall back on if that happens.

Features in Depth

01

Escape-Room-Meets-Jigsaw Puzzle Format

Puzzle Sections Five, building to one image Players Supported 1-2 Total Pieces About 300

This board game combines an escape room with a jigsaw puzzle in one box. Solving riddles earns new puzzle pieces, and the box itself opens in stages like an advent calendar, revealing five separate puzzle sections that eventually assemble into one larger image of a mansion. The combination is what sets it apart: riddle-heavy games such as the Exit and Unlock series barely use a jigsaw, while many escape puzzles are a full jigsaw with a single riddle at the end. Here each small jigsaw contains the clues to its own riddle, so the two halves feed each other, and the final puzzle adds a twist that is best left unspoiled. Anyone expecting a straightforward jigsaw or a pure riddle book should adjust their expectations first.

$26.99 4.2/5 Check price
02

Flexible Pacing With a Story-Driven Structure

Timer Optional Hardest Section The first Typical Playtime One evening to a few sessions

You can play with or without a time limit: set a timer for the full escape-room feel, or take your time and discuss the mystery at your own pace. A confident solo player can finish it in one evening, while a parent and a twelve-year-old might spread it over about four hours across a couple of weeks; both are perfectly good ways to play. Difficulty is the point people disagree on. The riddles can be reasoned out logically rather than guessed, but the first compartment is the steepest, both because its riddle is tricky and because you are still learning how the decoder works, and some players will find the step between sections uneven. The spelling in the clues also reveals a European origin, which occasionally matters for a word puzzle. Because the box tells one continuous story, it is designed to be solved once per copy rather than replayed the same way twice.

$26.99 4.2/5 Check price
03

Cardboard Construction and Component Completeness

Box Weight 0.69 kg Material Cardboard Warranty None

The box is cardboard, weighing about 0.69 kilograms and measuring roughly 13.5 by 9 by 2 inches, sized for a shelf rather than a bulky board game box. The components are well made and nothing needs to be written on or cut up, so the whole thing can be repacked and passed on to a friend afterwards. The weak point is packing. Some boxes arrive with a compartment missing its listed contents, which can stall the game at the very first step, and a replacement copy is the usual fix. Identity Games doesn't offer a warranty on this game, so check each compartment against the contents printed on its flap as soon as the box arrives, and before the return window closes, rather than discovering the problem halfway through.

$26.99 4.2/5 Check price
04

Family Play Across a Range of Ages

Recommended Age 16+ Best Group Size 1-2 players Learning Curve Decoder clicks after section one

Identity Games recommends this for ages 16 and up, which is sensible guidance for playing without help. With an adult alongside, it works well for younger teenagers too, and a logical twelve- or thirteen-year-old can easily end up leading the riddle-solving. It makes a good shared project for a parent and child, especially without the timer. The instructions are the part to prepare for: they are brief, and the decoder is confusing until you have used it once, so have an adult read through the setup and the first section's rules before handing the box to a younger player.

$26.99 4.2/5 Check price

How We Scored It

Based on
The manufacturer's published specifications and the product's live Amazon listing.
Owner rating
4.4 out of 5 on Amazon, recorded October 4, 2026
How we score
We score each thing that comes up most in owner feedback on the Escape Room. Seven things come up most in owner feedback: four draw praise, one splits opinion and two draw mostly complaints. Its ratings average 4.4 stars (73% five stars, 13% four, 6% three and 8% one or two), so every score starts at 88, that average on a 100 point scale. Where opinion is split, we take off 6. Where it draws mostly complaints, we take off 12. Then we read six owner reviews in full (every one we found gave it four or five stars) and move the score up to 5 points either way depending on how the owners who mention it rated the product. Our overall score starts from the same 4.4 star average and loses 0.1 for each thing that draws mostly complaints, with 0.1 more when at least a tenth of ratings are one star, never more than 0.3 in all. Here that takes off 0.2, which gives 4.2. Read our editorial standards

Gameplay

None of the six owner reviews we read mention it. Score 88: its 4.4 star average on a 100 point scale.

88Positive

Quality

One of the six owner reviews we read mentions it. That owner gave the product four or five stars. Score 88: its 4.4 star average on a 100 point scale.

88Positive

Variety

None of the six owner reviews we read mention it. Score 88: its 4.4 star average on a 100 point scale.

88Positive

Complexity

Two of the six owner reviews we read mention it, and those owners gave the product four or five stars, so the complaints come from the wider group of buyers. None of the reviews we read say what goes wrong, so this score rests on the buyer ratings. 14% of all ratings are three stars or fewer, which is where complaints like this usually sit. Score 82: we started at 88 and took off 6 because opinion…

Read the full note (410 characters)

Two of the six owner reviews we read mention it, and those owners gave the product four or five stars, so the complaints come from the wider group of buyers. None of the reviews we read say what goes wrong, so this score rests on the buyer ratings. 14% of all ratings are three stars or fewer, which is where complaints like this usually sit. Score 82: we started at 88 and took off 6 because opinion is split.

82Mixed

Instructions

None of the six owner reviews we read mention it. 14% of all ratings are three stars or fewer, which is where complaints like this usually sit. Score 76: we started at 88 and took off 12 because it draws mostly complaints.

76Needs Improvement

Missing Pieces

Three of the six owner reviews we read mention it, and those owners gave the product four or five stars, so the complaints come from the wider group of buyers. None of the reviews we read say what goes wrong, so this score rests on the buyer ratings. 14% of all ratings are three stars or fewer, which is where complaints like this usually sit. Score 76: we started at 88 and took off 12 because it d…

Read the full note (423 characters)

Three of the six owner reviews we read mention it, and those owners gave the product four or five stars, so the complaints come from the wider group of buyers. None of the reviews we read say what goes wrong, so this score rests on the buyer ratings. 14% of all ratings are three stars or fewer, which is where complaints like this usually sit. Score 76: we started at 88 and took off 12 because it draws mostly complaints.

76Needs Improvement

Owner Satisfaction

73% of ratings are five stars and 13% are four. 6% are three stars and 8% are one or two. The spread skews positive, but enough ratings sit low that the drawbacks below are worth reading. Score 88: its 4.4 star average on a 100 point scale.

88Positive

Specifications

Size and weight

Item Dimensions L x W
13.07"L x 1.69"W
Item Dimensions
13.5 x 9 x 2 inches
Item Weight
0.69 kg

Materials and warranty

Material Type
Cardboard
Included Components
Puzzle game

Performance

Age Range Description
Age 16+

What Buyers Say

Based on 595 Amazon customer ratings, averaging 4.4 out of 5, recorded 12 September 2026. See the reviews on Amazon

5 stars 73%
4 stars 13%
3 stars 6%
2 stars 3%
1 stars 5%
★★★★★

Fantastic Puzzle Game System! (MINOR SPOILERS)

This system is such an excellent hybrid of game and puzzle! In the past I’ve done several of the Exit and Unlock games, which are pretty much all riddles, and I’ve done a few of the Ravensbu… Read it on Amazon
OnePieceAtATime · May 9, 2021 · Verified
★★★★★

components missing...EDITED

I ordered this for my 13-year-old nephew and I as he LOVES escape rooms and we have used this brand before. We opened it, punched out the parts, read the intro, opened the first flap...and f… Read it on Amazon
Amy S. · June 25, 2021 · Verified
★★★★★

One of the best puzzle experiences out there!

I love puzzles and have done a lot of in-box experiences, and this is one of the best. It's a terrific combination of jigsaw and thought puzzles, with both type just challenging enough to be… Read it on Amazon
L. Shannon · November 28, 2023 · Verified
★★★★★

Good quality, can play, repack and pass on

This was such a fun game! You can either time yourself and try to do it as fast as possible, like in a IRL escape room, or just put the clock aside and do your own pace. I did the latter.The… Read it on Amazon
Cyllene · June 20, 2021 · Verified
★★★★★

Challenging and Rewarding

My 12 yr old son and I really enjoyed doing this escape room. It took us roughly 4 hours over a couple week period. He has a logical thinking brain, whereas I do not. He really took the lead… Read it on Amazon
Katie S. · March 11, 2026 · Verified
★★★★★

Perfect for game night

Me and my bf really love escape games, we normally play a different brand but I thought we would give this a try and we loved it! This one is puzzle based (to varying degrees of difficulty) … Read it on Amazon
Sarita Tailor · January 11, 2022 · Verified

Setting It Up

  1. Read the Story

    Open the first compartment and read the story printed on the inside flap before doing anything else, since it sets up what you're looking for.

  2. Assemble the Room Puzzle

    Take the puzzle pieces from the opened compartment and assemble them to form a room. This is one of five sections that eventually build one larger image.

  3. Solve the Riddles

    Work through the riddles tied to that compartment to arrive at a code, made up of numbers or shapes.

  4. Use the Puzzle Decoder

    Place the key pieces into the puzzle decoder and convert your code into a symbol.

  5. Open the Matching Compartment

    Find that symbol on the box and open the compartment it points to, then start again from reading the next piece of story.

  6. Set Your Own Pace

    Race against a timer for the full escape-room feel, or set the clock aside and take as long as you like. It's entirely up to you.

Common Questions

What's actually inside the box, and how does the escape-room-plus-jigsaw-puzzle idea work?

You solve riddles to earn puzzle pieces, and the box itself opens in stages like an advent calendar. There are five separate puzzle sections in total, about 300 pieces altogether, each one part of a larger image of a mansion, plus a puzzle-style decoder for checking your answers. So this isn't a traditional large jigsaw so much as five smaller puzzles tied together by a story.

How many people can play, and is it worth it solo?

It's built for one or two players, and both work well. Solo, it makes a satisfying single evening. As a pair, it divides naturally, with one person stronger on the jigsaws and the other on the riddles. More than two people tends to be too many around one small puzzle.

What age is this really meant for?

Identity Games recommends it for ages 16 and up. With an adult alongside, younger teenagers can enjoy it too, and a logical twelve- or thirteen-year-old may well end up leading the riddle-solving. Without the timer it makes a good family project.

How long does it take to finish, and can you replay it afterward?

It depends on the group and the pace. An experienced solo player can finish in one evening; a parent and child might take around four hours spread over a couple of weeks. Since it's one continuous story building to a single resolution, it's designed to be solved once per copy, but nothing needs to be written on, so it can be repacked and passed on to someone new afterward.

Are missing pieces a problem?

Occasionally. Some boxes arrive with a compartment that doesn't contain what its flap lists, which can stop the game before it starts. A replacement copy usually solves it. Identity Games doesn't offer a warranty on this game, so check every compartment's contents as soon as the box arrives, while you can still return it.

Is the difficulty level consistent, or does it vary a lot?

It varies. The first compartment is usually the hardest, partly because the riddle is tricky and partly because you are still learning how the decoder works. After that it tends to flow more smoothly. The riddles can be worked out logically rather than guessed, which keeps frustration down, but some players will still find the jump between sections uneven.

On Video

6 videos

Easy to make math game

Build Math Minds
All videos
  1. Easy to make math game Build Math Minds
  2. How to Travel with Board Games ✈️ Pocket Party
  3. The Surgery To Reveal More Teeth 😨 Zack D. Films
  4. Can You Guess the Word? 🧠 Picture Puzzles & Brain Game Challenge | Adi Connection #shorts Adi Connection
  5. Genius Student is Faster than a Calculator 🧠 Movie Boo
  6. Simple question 👀 Bukkit Brown

The Verdict

4.2Out of 5

Secret of the Scientist succeeds by combining two things that usually come separately: a real jigsaw puzzle and a genuine mystery you have to solve, all inside a single advent-calendar-style box. Five compartments open in sequence as you solve riddles, each one moving the story and the mansion image forward, and you can play against a timer or at your own pace. The gameplay is clever and varied, and the riddles are fair. The drawbacks are thin instructions that make the first section harder than it needs to be, and boxes that occasionally arrive incomplete. Best suited to one or two players who want a single, absorbing evening or two of story-driven puzzling rather than a fast, repeatable escape room.

Who should buy it

  • Jigsaw fans who want a mystery attached
  • Couples or parent-and-child pairs who want to split riddle-solving and puzzle-assembling between two people
  • Anyone who wants the choice to play against a clock or take their time over multiple sessions
  • Buyers happy to check a box's compartments carefully on arrival, since there's no manufacturer warranty

Secret of the Scientist delivers a genuine hybrid of jigsaw puzzle and escape-room mystery in one box, with fair riddles and a clever finish; just check it arrives complete and give the first section a little patience.

Check price on Amazon

More Reviews